The best 4-cup coffee maker is the OXO Brew 9-Cup Coffee Maker. It has a dedicated small-batch mode, so 4 cups taste as good as a full pot. On a budget, the Mr. Coffee 5-Cup is the one to get.
Four cups is the sweet spot for one or two coffee drinkers. That's roughly 20 oz, or two big mugs, since coffee maker "cups" are about 5 oz each.
I've considered any drip machine that brews 4 cups well, meaning 4 cups isn't at the extreme end of its range. Many big machines brew weak, uneven coffee at small volumes, so this matters more than the number on the box. I own a Breville Precision Brewer, which brews small batches well, and I also dug into owners' experiences.
- Best overall: OXO Brew 9-Cup
- Cheapest I can recommend: Mr. Coffee 5-Cup
- Best possible coffee: Ratio Six
- Best for small counters: Bonavita 5-Cup
Best Overall: OXO Brew 9-Cup Coffee Maker
OXO Brew 9-Cup Coffee Maker
Excellent coffee at small and large batch sizes, for a reasonable price.
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Coffee Quality: 9/10
Very good, second only to the Ratio Six in blind tastings. It's SCA certified, so it holds the ideal brewing temperature throughout. In James Hoffmann's well-known test of certified brewers, the OXO came second, behind the Ratio Six, and he noted the gaps between certified brewers were small.
For a 4-cup machine, the key feature is its small-batch setting: tell it you're brewing fewer cups and it focuses the water on a smaller area of grounds. That keeps a small batch from tasting thin.
Design and Build Quality: 8/10
High quality inside and out. Its thermal carafe keeps coffee hot and pours without dripping, which is surprisingly rare. Only the thin plastic brew button feels cheap.
Value: 9/10
Excellent value. It's far from the most expensive drip machine, yet it makes coffee as good as nearly any of them.
Why buy it: great value, excellent coffee, a drip-free carafe, consistent at any batch size, programmable start. Why skip it: a slightly cheap-feeling button; bigger than a dedicated small machine.
Cheapest I Can Recommend: Mr. Coffee 5-Cup
Mr. Coffee 5-Cup Coffee Maker
Simple, small and famously long-lasting.
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Coffee Quality: 6/10
Not in the same league as the others, but good for the price. It isn't SCA certified and doesn't hold the ideal temperature throughout, which caps how good it can taste. Still, it's a long-standing r/Coffee recommendation as a first drip machine, and owners consistently say it beats other cheap brewers.
Design and Build Quality: 7/10
Built to last rather than to impress. Owners regularly report Mr. Coffee machines running for 10 years or more. For the price, that's hard to beat.
Value: 10/10
Excellent value. It costs a fraction of the others and is very compact, small enough for a desk or a dorm.
Why buy it: very cheap, very reliable, tiny footprint. Why skip it: not as good as SCA-certified machines, a glass carafe on a hot plate, rough water markings.
Best Possible Coffee: Ratio Six
Ratio Six
The best-tasting drip coffee here, if flavor matters most.
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Coffee Quality: 10/10
The best here. It won Hoffmann's taste test of certified brewers. Its well-insulated brew basket keeps heat in throughout the brew, and its showerhead wets the coffee bed more evenly than most.
Design and Build Quality: 7/10
Excellent brewing internals, one big flaw: the water tank markings are inaccurate. To get the ratio right, measure water with a jug or scale. For an expensive machine, that's disappointing.
Value: 5/10
Only worth it if coffee quality comes first. It's the priciest here, for a small improvement in taste.
Why buy it: the best coffee here, very little plastic, beautiful. Why skip it: inaccurate water markings, expensive.
Best for Small Counters: Bonavita 5-Cup
Bonavita 5-Cup Coffee Maker
SCA-certified brewing in the smallest footprint here.
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Coffee Quality: 8/10
Excellent, and only slightly behind the OXO and Ratio. It's SCA certified, so it holds a steady brewing temperature. Its showerhead covers the grounds a little less evenly, but most people won't notice.
Design and Build Quality: 6/10
Great internals, plasticky outside, and a drippy carafe. Expect to wipe the counter after pouring. On the plus side, it's very compact, and at a 5-cup max, 4 cups is right in its comfort zone.
Value: 9/10
Excellent value for an SCA-certified brewer. It has become harder to find in some stores, so if it's unavailable, go for the OXO. More in my Bonavita review.
Why buy it: affordable, great coffee, very compact. Why skip it: 5-cup maximum, drippy carafe.
What Matters When Choosing
Steady Brewing Temperature
You want 195°F to 205°F from start to finish. Most machines only get there by the end, so most of the coffee brews too cool. Machines that hold the range throughout can earn SCA certification.
| Holds ideal temperature | SCA certified | |
|---|---|---|
| OXO Brew 9-Cup | Yes | Yes |
| Mr. Coffee 5-Cup | No | No |
| Ratio Six | Yes | Yes |
| Bonavita 5-Cup | Yes | Yes |
Good Small-Batch Performance
With only 4 cups of water, a machine designed for 12 can splash a thin stream over part of the grounds and finish too fast. Look for a small-batch mode (like the OXO's) or a machine whose maximum is close to 4 to 6 cups (like the Bonavita or Mr. Coffee).
Bloom
A bloom step improves flavor. A little water first lets the grounds release CO2, so the rest of the brew extracts properly and evenly.
| Blooms before brewing | |
|---|---|
| OXO Brew 9-Cup | Yes |
| Mr. Coffee 5-Cup | No |
| Ratio Six | Yes |
| Bonavita 5-Cup | No |
Carafe
A thermal carafe that pours cleanly is ideal. A glass carafe on a hot plate slowly cooks the coffee and makes it bitter, though with only 4 cups you'll probably drink it fast. Glass carafes do usually pour cleanly; thermal ones often splutter. More in my best coffee makers with a thermal carafe.
| Carafe | Pours cleanly | |
|---|---|---|
| OXO Brew 9-Cup | Thermal | Yes |
| Mr. Coffee 5-Cup | Glass | Yes |
| Ratio Six | Thermal | Yes |
| Bonavita 5-Cup | Thermal | No |
Accurate Water Markings
These machines brew whatever water you add, so markings need to be clear and accurate. Many aren't.
| Clear | Accurate | |
|---|---|---|
| OXO Brew 9-Cup | Yes | Yes |
| Mr. Coffee 5-Cup | Yes | No |
| Ratio Six | Yes | No |
| Bonavita 5-Cup | Yes | Yes |
Auto-On
Not essential, but handy: load it at night and wake up to coffee. Of these, only the OXO has a programmable start.
The Bottom Line
The best 4-cup coffee maker is the OXO Brew 9-Cup, an excellent all-rounder that brews small batches properly. If you're on a tight budget, get the Mr. Coffee 5-Cup; if you want the best cup, the Ratio Six.
Brewing a little more? See my best 5-cup coffee makers. Only ever drinking one cup? See my best single-serve coffee makers without pods.
FAQs
How many ounces is a 4-cup coffee maker?
Usually about 20 oz, since most brands count a cup as about 5 oz. That's roughly two large mugs.
Can I brew 4 cups in a 12-cup coffee maker?
You can, but many big machines brew weak, uneven coffee at small volumes. Choose one with a small-batch setting, like the OXO.
What's the best cheap small coffee maker?
The Mr. Coffee 5-Cup. It's inexpensive, compact and known for lasting years.
Written by · reviewed by the Cicada Coffee Bar team
Daniel Voss
Lead Equipment Reviewer, Cicada Coffee Bar
Daniel leads the equipment-testing side of Cicada Coffee Bar. Every super-automatic, semi-automatic, and grinder featured on this site is bought or sourced independently, set up on the test bench, and brewed with daily for at least two weeks before a single word is written — tracking espresso quality, milk texture, ease of cleaning, and long-term reliability. Reviews are updated whenever pricing or firmware changes.
